The Questionables

"It's innocence when it charms us, ignorance when it doesn't." --Mignon McLaughlin

Within the canon of published literature lie a number of books on the borders. Some people advocate reading these works for their worldviews; others believe it is best to turn away from any questionable --or downright despicable-- works in order to preserve as much innocence or purity as possible. Generally I am fond of the former, with certain exceptions: young children, or even older children, should be encouraged to wait as long as is possible before turning to the less desirable books, and certain books are even too abhorrent for words. I have read a few of these, but fortunately, not many; I generally encourage my friends to stay far, far away from them.

Magic, as in fantasy books, is an odd line; some Christians dismiss the Harry Potter books for their promotions of magic; others dismidss even the Christian authors J. R. R. Tolkien and C. S. Lewis for the same reasons. Others still enjoy and appreciate all or most of it. For myself, I will read about magic and fantasy. For others, I encourage the Christian authors, especially Tolkien and Lewis, almost without qualms, but inform parents that the Rowling (Harry Potter) books are only at their own discretion: borrow one from the library, read it, and decide. If or when I have my own children, I would set an age limit on the really questionable books. I didn't read Rowling until I was righteen, and I certainly didn't suffer for it. A great deal depends on the maturity of the reader.

This page seeks to review the difficult books, with as little prejudice as is possible, and then discuss their worldviews, merits, and flaws in order to provide readers with some forewarning of questionable matter or scenes.

His Dark Materials Book I: The Golden Compass by Philip Pullman

Worldview: self-proclaimed "Christian Atheist," anti-Religion, probably Agnostic

The Golden Compass, the first book in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series, tells the story of young Lyra Belacqua, who lives awith the Master of Oxford in a world not unlike our own. With her daemon Pantalaimon and her guiding alethiometer, which always tells the truth, she is thrown almost by chance into an adventure dealing with the mysterious substance "dust," the evil "gobblers" who steal and destroy children, and the powers that create windows or doors between worlds. As the adults that surround Lyra alow themselves to be caught up in violence and greed, Lyra tries to save nearly everyone she meets. One flaw of the book and the series is the lack of morality: good and evil are never defined, and what the readers believe good is often not, or vice versa.

Violence: Mostly emotional
Recommended Age: 16+
Bookworm says: Good writing, bad theory
Rating: Varies

His Dark Materials Book II: The Subtle Knife by Philip Pullman

Worldview: self-proclaimed "Christian Atheist," anti-Religion, probably Agnostic

The Subtle Knife, the second book in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series, continues the story of Lyra while introducing the character of Will, who comes from "our" world and meets Lyra by chance after she has stepped through a window between the worlds. In the new world, very similar to our own, many of the adults are being destroyed by bloodthirsty Specters, who feed on adults and have decimated the population. Lyra, however, meets the charming Professor Malone, who has been researching a substance not unlike dust. As Lyra seeks the truth, she and Will are hampered by the presence of Mrs. Coulter, Lyra's guardian from book I, the theft of Lyra's alethiometer, and a drastic battle in which Will ends up with a magical knife which can slice a window between worlds. The truth about Lyra's identity is also revealed.

Violence: Physical with emotional side effects
Recommended Age: 16+
Bookworm says: Good writing, bad theory
Rating: Varies

His Dark Materials Book III: The Amber Spyglass by Philip Pullman

Worldview: self-proclaimed "Christian Atheist," anti-Religion, probably Agnostic

The Amber Spyglass, the third book in Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series, and by far the most disturbing, continues the story of Lyra and will and also tells of the major attack upon the church and God planned by Lord Azrael and Mrs. Coulter. While armies gather to defy and defeat God (who is not really God), the "temptress" sets out in search of Lyra (unknowingly) to re-enact the scene with Eve in the Garden of Eden. Meanwhile, Lyra and Will journey into the Land of the Dead to save the dead, and Lyra for once in her life learns that only the truth will save her. After the dead are freed, Lyra's temptress draws nearer, as well as a mercenary hired to kill her so she cannot fall as Eve did. The Dust also begins to disappear, which greatly disturbs several people. At the final battle, readers are again shocked at the lack of clarity between good and evil. God evaporates, and Lyra meets her temptation. Though she falls, it is perceived as a good thing. Then Lyra and Will, now in love, are asked to make the ultimate sacrifice.

Violence: Physical with emotional side effects
Recommended Age: 18+
Bookworm says: Longwinded, disturbing content
Rating: Avoid

Return to the Main page. Or...
Children's List Youth List Adult List Nonfiction List Poetry List Pick of the Month Christmas Picks
Quotations Guestbook Links Perspectives Site Mission
Tribute Thanks
Click here to contact me.
You are visitor number 495 to this page.
This page was last updated 2002 May 24.